Casey Key

Welcome to Casey Key




Casey Key is a picturesque barrier island located in the Gulf of Mexico, just off the coast of Sarasota and Manatee County in Florida. This exclusive island is known for its luxurious homes, pristine beaches, and serene atmosphere, making it a highly sought after destination for both tourists and residents alike.

The island is approximately 8 miles long and only 300 feet wide, giving it a secluded and intimate feel. It is accessible by a single bridge at the northern end, which adds to its exclusivity and privacy. The island is home to a small but affluent community, with a population of around 400 residents.

One of the main draws of Casey Key is its stunning beaches. The island is surrounded by crystal clear waters and boasts over 7 miles of white sandy beaches, perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and water sports. The beaches are also known for their abundance of shells, making it a popular spot for shell collectors. The warm and sunny climate of Florida makes Casey Key an ideal place to enjoy the beach year-round.

In addition to its natural beauty, Casey Key is also known for its luxurious homes and estates. Many of the properties on the island are multi-million dollar mansions, owned by celebrities, CEOs, and other affluent individuals. These homes are often situated on large lots, providing residents with plenty of space and privacy. The architecture on the island varies from modern and contemporary to Mediterranean and Key West-style, adding to the charm and diversity of the community.

Despite its small size, Casey Key offers a variety of activities and amenities for residents and visitors. The island has a number of boutique shops, restaurants, and art galleries, providing a unique and upscale shopping and dining experience. Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy activities such as boating, fishing, and kayaking, while nature lovers can explore the island's wildlife and nature preserves.

Casey Key is also known for its tight-knit community and friendly atmosphere. The island hosts a variety of events and festivals throughout the year, bringing residents together and fostering a sense of community. The island also has its own volunteer fire department and community association, ensuring the safety and well-being of its residents.

In conclusion, Casey Key is a charming and exclusive island community with a laid-back yet luxurious lifestyle. Its natural beauty, high-end properties, and tight-knit community make it a highly desirable place to live or visit in Sarasota or Manatee County.


Local Lifestyle


Casey Key is one of Sarasota County's most desirable communities—where coastal charm meets elegant living. With sugar-white beaches, the calm waters of the Intracoastal Waterway, and an array of homes in styles ranging from coastal contemporary to Mediterranean, this area offers a lifestyle unlike any other. Whether you're dreaming of a relaxed beachside retreat or a spacious home near top-rated schools and golf courses, Karen Jorgensen is your trusted local real estate expert. We specialize in Sarasota County and its surrounding neighborhoods, offering exclusive access to “just listed” homes in this vibrant coastal region.

You've earned the chance to live where every day feels like a vacation. Start by imagining the features that matter most to you—whether it's sunset views over the Gulf, walkability to cafés and art galleries, or a peaceful backyard oasis. From luxurious estates on Siesta Key and waterfront villas on Lido or Bird Key, to family-friendly homes in Palmer Ranch or Venice, Sarasota County offers something for everyone. Let us help you explore each neighborhood's unique character so you can find a home that fits your lifestyle perfectly.



Contact Karen Jorgensen at 407.808.3118 today for a tour of the area.
 
 
 

View Casey Key Homes


Featured Properties

Browse the available properties in the area below.

Work With Us

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.